Select Page

Can You Go to Jail for Not Paying Restitution? – Explained

by | Jun 12, 2024 | Finances | 0 comments

Restitution is a court-ordered payment that a convicted offender must make to the victim of their crime to compensate for financial losses or damages. It is a common condition of probation or a suspended sentence, requiring the defendant to pay a specified amount to the victim. Failure to pay court-ordered restitution can lead to serious legal consequences, including jail time.

What is Restitution and When is it Required?

Understanding Court-Ordered Restitution

Court-ordered restitution is a payment mandated by the court as part of a criminal sentence. It is often a condition of probation or a suspended sentence, meaning that the defendant must pay restitution to remain out of jail. The purpose of restitution is to compensate the victim for any financial losses or damages resulting from the crime.

Restitution can cover a wide range of expenses, such as medical bills, property damage, lost wages, and counseling costs. The court determines the amount of restitution based on the victim’s losses and the defendant’s ability to pay. Failing to pay court-ordered restitution can result in serious legal consequences, including revocation of probation and imprisonment.

Mandatory Restitution Under Federal Law

Under federal law, restitution is mandatory in certain cases. The Mandatory Victims Restitution Act (MVRA), codified in 18 USC Section 3663A, requires courts to order restitution for victims of specified offenses, including crimes of violence, property crimes, and fraud. This means that defendants convicted of these crimes must pay restitution as part of their sentence.

In white-collar crime cases, such as fraud, embezzlement, and securities offenses, restitution often involves returning the money or property taken from the victim. The defendant may also be required to pay additional expenses incurred by the victim, such as legal fees or lost investment income. Failure to pay mandatory restitution can result in severe penalties, including lengthy prison sentences.

Consequences of Failing to Pay Restitution

Probation Revocation and Imprisonment

One of the most serious consequences of failing to pay restitution is the revocation of probation. If restitution is a condition of probation, the court can revoke probation and send the defendant to jail for violating the terms of their release. The court must find that the failure to pay was willful, meaning that the defendant had the ability to pay but chose not to.

If probation is revoked, the defendant may be required to serve the remainder of their suspended sentence in prison. In some cases, the court may impose additional jail time as punishment for the violation. It is important to note that the court cannot impose additional imprisonment if the defendant has already completed their term of supervised release.

Civil Judgments and Legal Actions

In addition to criminal penalties, failing to pay restitution can result in civil legal actions. The court may convert the unpaid restitution into a civil judgment, which allows the victim to pursue collection through wage garnishment, liens on property, or other means. The judgment remains in effect until the restitution is paid in full.

Prosecutors may also take legal action to ensure payment of restitution. They may file a motion to hold the defendant in civil contempt of court for failing to comply with the restitution order. If the court finds the defendant in contempt, they may be fined or even jailed until they make payment arrangements.

Contempt of Court Charges

Failing to pay restitution can also result in criminal or civil contempt of court charges. Criminal contempt involves a willful violation of a court order and can result in a determinate jail sentence. Civil contempt is used to compel compliance with a court order and typically results in imprisonment until the defendant complies.

In the context of restitution, a defendant may be held in civil contempt if they have the means to pay but refuse to do so. The court may impose a fine or jail sentence to coerce payment. The defendant can be released from custody upon payment of the owed restitution or a good faith effort to comply with the order.

Defenses for Failure to Pay Restitution

Proving Inability to Afford Payments

One defense against a violation of probation for failure to pay restitution is the inability to afford the payments. The burden of proof lies on the defendant to demonstrate that they lack the financial means to pay the ordered restitution. This may involve presenting evidence of income, expenses, assets, and liabilities.

To succeed with this defense, the defendant must show that they made legitimate efforts to acquire the money to pay restitution. This may include seeking employment, borrowing from family or friends, or selling assets. The court will consider the defendant’s financial situation and efforts to pay when determining whether to revoke probation.

Alternative Measures Like Community Service

In some cases, the court may impose alternative measures in lieu of jail time for failure to pay restitution. One common alternative is community service. The defendant may be required to perform a specified number of hours of community service in place of monetary restitution.

Other alternatives may include job training, counseling, or drug treatment programs. The court may also modify the restitution order to reduce the amount owed or extend the payment timeline. These alternatives are typically reserved for defendants who demonstrate a genuine inability to pay and a willingness to take responsibility for their actions.

Seeking Legal Help for Restitution Issues

If you are facing a violation of probation for failure to pay restitution, it is essential to seek the advice of a qualified criminal defense attorney. An experienced lawyer can help you understand your legal options and develop a strategy to defend against the violation.

Your attorney can review your financial situation and gather evidence to support a claim of inability to pay. They can also negotiate with the prosecutor or court to seek alternative measures or a modification of the restitution order. In some cases, an attorney may be able to have the violation dismissed or the restitution order vacated.

Consequence Description
Probation Revocation The court can revoke probation and impose the original jail sentence for failure to pay restitution.
Civil Judgment Unpaid restitution can be converted into a civil judgment, allowing the victim to pursue collection through wages or property.
Contempt of Court The court can hold a defendant in criminal or civil contempt for willfully failing to pay restitution.

Failing to pay court-ordered restitution can result in serious legal consequences, including jail time. If you are struggling to make restitution payments, it is important to communicate with your probation officer and seek the advice of a criminal defense attorney. With the right legal strategy, you may be able to avoid a violation of probation and resolve your restitution obligations in a manageable way.

See also: